When an employee consistently takes longer lunch breaks than scheduled, it can be frustrating for business owners and managers. But what happens when that employee is salaried and exempt from overtime? Can you deduct the extra time from their paid time off (PTO), or are there rules you need to follow?
You could deduct hours from an exempt employee’s PTO bank for time they were scheduled to work but didn’t work, but if it wasn’t made clear to them that they were expected to follow a set schedule, you’d only want to do this going forward and once you have a policy in place. However, we’d suggest you consider a different approach.
The first and best step with any performance or behavior problem is simply to talk to the employee. It’s possible they simply misunderstand how long lunch breaks are supposed to be, and they’re taking what they believe to be the correct amount of time. Either way, ensure they understand what the consequences will be if they continue to take long lunch breaks. This discussion alone will likely solve the problem.
If the too-long lunch breaks persist, follow your standard disciplinary process. While PTO deductions are an option, they may not actually discourage the behavior you want to stop. If the employee is willing to use PTO to take long lunches, they may just continue taking them. Additionally, as this employee’s position is classified as exempt, once their PTO bank is exhausted, a deduction from their salary for missed time would not be permissible.
This Q&A does not constitute legal advice and does not address state or local law.
Recent Comments